This tandoori marinade is loaded with big Indian flavours. If you can grill, you can make better tandoori chicken than you can buy.
I don’t know why it is but the tandoori chicken in restaurants in North America is just not good. Maybe it’s marinated too long. Maybe it’s overcooked. Maybe they use mass produced tandoori paste. For sure is nowhere as good as it could be.
Which is too bad because it’s one of the great chicken dishes of all time. I use tandoori marinade all over the place. Tandoori chicken – sure. But tandoori tacos. And chicken tikka. Shashlik. Or rotisserie up a whole tandoor chicken. Why not?
Think of this recipe as an alternative to store bought tandoori paste. It is tandoori paste when you think about it. Just homemade. Fresher. Tastier.
Grill or oven?
My favourite way to cook tandoori chicken is to grill over charcoal. That little hint of smoke just makes it magic for me. If I had a tandoor maybe that would be my favourite.
But if you can’t get to your grill the oven works too. Slather the chicken. Roast the chicken on a rack. Hit it with a blast of the broiler at the end to crisp it up a bit. Beautiful.
That works especially well for chicken tikka. Kebabs just work well in the oven for some reason. That’s what I do in the dead of winter to get my tandoori fix.
Tandoori marinade is better without yoghurt
I’m a bit of a heretic when it comes to tandoori marinade. I don’t like to include yoghurt. That goes against pretty much every tandoori recipe out there.
But there’s a reason. Yoghurt and other acidic marinades break down the proteins in the chicken. Think of ceviche. That is fish cooked with nothing but acid. No heat at all.
That pre-cooking effect turns chicken into mush. Terrible texture. Just not tasty. You can try to fix it by cooking it over crazy high temperature.
That helps some as long as you don’t overcook it. That’s what a tandoor oven does. Searingly high temperatures.
Or you can set yourself up for success from the start. Leave the yoghurt out of your tandoori marinade. Break with tradition. It’s not that scary. Honest.
Tips from a Bangalore tandoori restaurant
I came to this conclusion after eating at a tandoori kebab restaurant in Bangalore. Their chicken was moist, the flavours explosive. So good.
I thought about it for a while then asked “Do you use yoghurt in your tandoori paste?”. “No, we don’t”. Haven’t used yoghurt since. I add the lemon at the end. I don’t get mush and nor will you.
Don’t let the list of ingredients stop you
There’s a lot of ingredients in this marinade. The recipe works really well as written. But it won’t completely fall apart if you leave one out. Even two.
But each ingredient adds a little something. And the combination is what makes this recipe special. Complexity. This isn’t a one-dimensional tandoori marinade.
It might seem harder than it needs to be but all you are doing is mixing some stuff up in a bowl. Nothing more involved than that. Dump some stuff in a bowl and mix. Not so hard.
And it’s going to be better than you have been getting at your local Indian restaurant. Unless you live in India I guess. Then it will just be as good.
Try it to make really good chicken tikka, tandoori chicken or even tandoori tacos. Oven or grill or tandoor. Start with a great tandoori marinade and you’ll get great tandoori chicken.
tandoori marinade
Ingredients
- 1 Tbsp cumin powder
- 1 Tbsp coriander powder
- 2 tsp hot curry powder
- 1 tsp turmeric
- 1 Tbsp dried fenugreek leaves aka kasoor methi
- 2 tsp salt
- 1 tsp mint sauce
- 2 tsp mild kashmiri chili powder
- 1 Tbsp chopped coriander leaf/stem
- 1 Tbsp Patak's tandoori paste optional
- 1 Tbsp garlic ginger paste
- 3 Tbsp oil
- 4-6 Tbsp water to make a runny paste
- pinch red food colouring
- Juice of 1/2 lemon
Instructions
- Combine all the ingredients except the water and the lemon juice.
- Add water, a bit at a time until you get a consistency like the picture.
- Marinate meat at least an hour and up to 12. Add the lemon juice just before cooking.
Hands down best tandoori Marinade ever. As close to the Indian restaurant quality as you will get .
Delighted to hear you liked it!
Best recipe. It came out really well
Glad you liked it!
Hello , the recipe looks great , I’d like to try it but I’m a bit confused over the nutritional values ! It says that it’s 478 calories per serving , so is that just the marinade or on the chicken ? And if it is on the chicken , how is the fat so high and the protein so low ?? I need to know because I eat low carbs high protein so have to watch ingredients, the carb count seems quite high too !! Please explain .
It is for the marinade alone. There is sugar in the mint sauce. The fat content comes from all the oil in the marinade.
Thank you for getting back to me…quickly. Cooking it now! I think your recipes are not all only fantastic, but so easy to follow. I’ve got at least 20 friends (who all thought they cooked fantastic curries) Raving about you thank you for these (now our favourite) curries. I’m trying the hotel curry gravy this week finger crossed
You are very welcome and thank you for the kind words. Hope you enjoy the hotel curry style as much as I have been!
I’ve added the lemon juice to the marinade instead just before cooking. Do i need to restart ..Thanks
The acid in the lemon juice denatures the protein (chicken) so if you keep your marination time short (say 30 minutes) you should be OK this time.
I just used your marinade for a tandoor chicken recipe on Serious Eat website. Thanks for the suggestion to leave out yogurt and lemon while marinating. I added it right before cooking to the recipe since it needed it for the sauce. Also I added fresh mint, fresh garlic and fresh ginger to the mix and it worked fine. The chicken was delicious.
Awesome to hear. And pretty pleased to mentioned in a comment alongside Serious Eats:-)
Lovely recipe. Best tikka i have ever made. The only problem i have is the chicken dries out. This is always my issue. Do i add oil?
Dry chicken is almost certainly an over-cooking problem. Oil will not fix it. White meat to a max of 165F and dark to a max of 175F and you will never have dry chicken again. An instant read thermometer is one of your best friends in the kitchen.
What oven temperature should I use and for how long? And then how long under the broiler. Thanks so much, I have been looking for a tandoori recipe without yogurt!
I would go around 375-400F to bake them off to about 165F for thighs and then under the broiler just long to get a little char on either side.
I find tikka works better than tandoori chicken in the oven (easier/cooks more evenly).
We’ve made this recipe for ourselves numerous times now, and for friends as well. It never ceases to impress. What I really love is how simple and easy it is to throw together ahead of time, and then toss it on the grill once friends come over. If you have a charcoal grill, it is absolutely worth the trouble to fire it up for this.
There is just something about cooking over charcoal that makes everything better!
Would love to make a large batch of this wonderful marinade – does it store well in the freezer?
It would likely freeze really well if you left out the water, cilantro and mint sauce. Just mix up the other ingredients and just freeze the “paste”. When you thaw it, mix in the cilantro and mint sauce. Dilute with the water to get your desired consistency and go. That way the cilantro and mint sauce would be as fresh as they can be. As the lemon goes in late in marination process you should leave that out and add it per the recipe.
Thank you for your recipe it was superb, had it with a family BBQ. Did chicken thighs marinated overnight, simply grilled on the BBQ and they were well acclaimed by everyone, they were so moist and tender.When I was preparing the marinade I realised I didn’t have any Hot Curry Powder so I used a teaspoon of a hot Cajun spice!! It seemed to work fine, will definitely do it again.
Glad it worked out for you! It’s one of my favourites. I haven’t tried it with cajun spice but I always have that around so I will give it a go. It does sound tasty that way!
I used this recipe as written with 6 chicken thighs and 6 drumsticks. I removed the skin and put the pieces in a zip lock bag with a double portion of the marinade which I left in the fridge for about 8 hours. The feedback was that this was the best tandoori chicken ever and that the chicken was very moist. After reading the comments here I realize now that I made a small mistake in using mint chutney which I though was what was meant by mint sauce. Searching around now, mint sauce doesn’t appear to be readily available in my area so next time I might have to improvise something. Either way it was a great success.
Glad it was a success. I have always loved this one!
I think, if you can get mint, it would be easy enough to make mint sauce.
Turned out restaurant quality! We grilled it on our gas grill.
Awesome to hear!
The coriander leaves, do they need to be dried or fresh
Thankyou
Always fresh. There are no recipes on glebekitchen that call for dried.